‘It all got out of hand’: Trial hears interviews with teen accused of murder of Limerick’s Scarlett

The late Scarlett Faulknerplaceholder image
The late Scarlett Faulkner | LL

The prosecution alleges that the 17-year-old inflicted all the injuries to Ms Faulkner using an iron bar

A TEENAGER who is accused of beating Limerick woman Scarlett Faulkner to death with a metal pole by the side of a busy road in County Tipperary told gardaí that it "all got out of hand" and "went too far".

"I don't think Scarlett deserved that, I think it wasn't fair on Scarlett," she said.

In her garda interviews, she accepted that she struck Ms Faulkner with the pole "a few times", adding that she was "angry, sad and overwhelmed" at seeing the deceased with a man who was married to the teenager's 41-year-old co-accused.

The now 17-year-old also told officers that if it wasn't for Scarlett Faulkner, "none of this would have happened".

She denied a suggestion by detectives that she had “got the job done” for her co-accused and said the other defendant hadn't touched Ms Faulkner.

The 41-year-old accused is alleged to have been part of a joint enterprise with the teenager to kill or cause serious injury to Ms Faulkner and the older accused's estranged husband, who had begun a relationship with the deceased.

She has pleaded not guilty to murder. They are both on trial at the Central Criminal Court.

The 17-year-old accused has pleaded not guilty to murder but guilty to manslaughter.

In his opening speech, Seoirse Ó Dúnlaing SC, prosecuting, told the jury that the motive for the attack was that 28-year-old Ms Faulkner had begun a relationship with the older accused's husband.

Mr Ó Dúnlaing said the prosecution would seek to prove that the accused "hunted down" her husband and Ms Faulkner for 24 hours up to about 5.20pm on March 21 last.

The lawyer said the older accused woman "rammed" her husband's van until both vehicles came to a stop near the Birdhill roundabout just off the M7 in Tipperary, between Limerick and Nenagh.

The prosecution alleges that the 17-year-old inflicted all the injuries to Ms Faulkner using an iron bar.

Scarlett Faulkner died on April 13 last after spending about three weeks in a coma.

Edward O'Mahony BL, prosecuting, this Wednesday took Garda Andrea Coonan through the teenager's five interviews conducted with detectives on March 26 and 27, 2026 at Thurles Garda Station.

In the teenager's first interview, gardaí told the then 16-year-old accused, who had been arrested on suspicion of conspiring to commit a serious offence, that it was very important to give her side of the story and tell them what had happened to Ms Faulkner.

"I know nothing about it," said the girl.

In the defendant's second interview, the teenager was asked whether she understood why she had been arrested. "Because of the assault... because you're saying I did it, that's why," she replied.

She later told the gardai "I don't know, you must think it was me".

The accused said she was very angry when she saw Ms Faulkner in a van with the older accused's husband on March 21 last.

She said the older accused's husband had started to ram the car she was travelling in and laughing at them.

"We were driving on the road and he was behind us on the road, he overtook us and he started stopping on the road so we were driving into him," she continued.

She said the older accused's husband was driving fast and breaking, agreeing with gardai that the cars were colliding.

The teenager said the two vehicles were hitting each other but she didn't know how long this was going on for.

"He was driving fast and stopping so we would ram into him....we drove into the back of him".

Asked by officers how they ended up stopping the vehicles, the accused said she couldn't remember as she was "so overwhelmed".

The teenager told gardai that the older accused's husband had hit Scarlett on the head with an axe in the van and that Ms Faulkner was trying to run away from him.

She said Ms Faulkner started running down the road begging all the cars to help her but she [Scarlett Faulkner] got knocked down by a car.

The teenager said she started hitting Ms Faulkner with the pole because she was "so angry" after seeing her with her co-accused's husband.

She said Ms Faulkner was already bleeding from her head when she caught up with her.

The accused said the pole was made of steel and she had taken it from the floor of the car she was travelling in.

"What were you thinking?" asked the gardai and the accused replied: "I was angry, I was sad, I was overwhelmed".

When the detectives asked her why she had picked up the pole, the accused said she was angry and that "it happened so fast I didn't think about it".

Asked on several occasions how many times she had hit Scarlett, the accused said "it all happened so fast I can't even remember".

Asked what way Ms Faulkner was when she left her, the teenager said it "genuinely happened in the blink of an eye, it happened so fast".

In the third interview, the accused said she was wearing her pyjamas when she followed Scarlett down the road and hit her "a few times" with the pole.

She went on to say she was so overwhelmed she couldn't remember how many times she hit her.

Asked in the fourth interview why Ms Faulkner had gotten out of the van and ran for her life, the accused said she didn't know. S

he again repeated that she was "very angry" when she saw Scarlett with her co-accused's husband.

The defendant went on to tell gardaí "it all got out of hand, everything that happened it all went too far".

"I don't think Scarlett deserved that, I think it wasn't fair on Scarlett," she added.

When gardaí put it to the teenager that she had left Ms Faulkner "lifeless" the teenager replied "yes but I didn't plan on doing it".

"Whether you know it or not, that's a plan driving around looking for her," stated gardai, which the accused agreed with.

In her fifth and final interview gardai asked the accused why she had gone so far.

"I wasn't thinking, I didn't want it to go so far," she replied.

"But you did" stated gardaí to which the teenager said "yes but I didn't mean to".

"I want to say I'm sorry for what happened to Scarlett Faulkner and I didn't mean it to go so far," concluded the teenager.

The trial continues before Mr Justice Kerida Naidoo and a jury of eight men and four women.

Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice