Poison-pen letters referred to wife’s cancer diagnosis, reveals University of Limerick president


Professor Shane Kilcommins made protected disclosure about UL’s controversial property deal in Rhebogue
THE PRESIDENT of the University of Limerick (UL) has spoken for the first time about being a whistleblower and receiving anonymous poison-pen letters.
Professor Shane Kilcommins told the Sunday Independent that the letters were “an absolute character assassination” and made reference to wife Maria’s cancer diagnosis.
The Galway native, in a wide-ranging interview with journalist Wayne O’Connor this Sunday, spoke about the repercussions he faced after he made a protected disclosure about a controversial UL property deal.
The university paid €12.65m in 2023 to buy 20 homes in Drominbeg, Rhebogue worth €7.425m.
UL was accused of “throwing money around like confetti” over the bill for the houses which did not have planning permission to be used as student accommodation at the time. Limerick Live revealed in October that retention planning permission was granted.
Before the August 2022 decision to buy the homes, legal and planning advice given to the university raised doubts about the suitability of the properties and how they were valued. This was kept from key decision-makers who approved the deal, reports the Sunday Independent.
Prof Kilcommins had just been appointed provost and deputy president of UL. The decision was approved at his first governing authority meeting, the highest decision-making body of a university, and one which signs off on planning and policy decisions.
He said he made his complaint after seeing documents about the deal in May 2023 while preparing for an appearance at the Dáil’s Public Accounts Committee.
“I said something needs to be done about this, but it was clear this would be difficult, that I would be on my own on this. When I wasn’t getting the traction I needed, I said going forward I am going to have to make a protected disclosure on this,” he told Mr O’Connor.
In July 2023, weeks after Prof Kilcommins raised concerns about the deal, 16 copies of an anonymous poison-pen letter were addressed to senior figures at the university.
Prof Kilcommins said he later learned from gardaí and after viewing CCTV footage taken from a post office in Limerick that a wife of a UL colleague put these letters in the post.
“It was an absolute character assassination. Five pages. Really personalised. There was a paragraph about my wife’s illness. It said I used my wife’s illness to promote my career, make myself look good and to get sympathy,” Prof Kilcommins told the Sunday Independent.
“It was clearly designed to get inside my head, to really upset me and in truth, it did,” he added.
Limerick Live revealed in September 2024 that gardai arrested a man following a complaint made over anonymous poison-pen letters addressed to individuals in the senior ranks of UL.
He was released without charge. A file was sent to the DPP, who directed that no prosecution be brought.
University Of Limerick appointed Professor Shane Kilcommins, who resided in Charleville for many years, in April. He had previously held the role of provost and deputy president and served as acting president since 2024.
The Sunday Independent article also reports that Professor Kilcommins said that soon after he first grew concerned about the Rhebogue deal, he was told to resign in the summer of 2023 by then UL president Kerstin Mey during a row about the purchase of the homes.
“She asked me to step down. In a sense, I was relieved. I had done my bit and I felt a burden was lifted. Later that day, she went back to the governing authority; the executive was reconvened and colleagues on the executive asked me to stay on,” he said.
Ms Mey resigned in the aftermath of the Rhebogue scandal, although she remains a lecturer at the university.
“Last year, UL admitted Prof Kilcommins’s protected disclosure was weaponised against him. It formally apologised to him in a letter signed by UL chancellor Brigid Laffan,” the Sunday Independent article states.
Limerick Live subsequently revealed that the position of president was initially offered to a UK-based academic before the appointment of Prof Kilcommins.
However, there was a groundswell of support for Prof Kilcommins within the university.
“The most important thing is that we put a gold-standard approach in, in terms of governance,” Prof Kilcommins said.
During the interview, the UL president also spoke about the university’s plans for Limerick city as it looks set to further expand its space. The former Dunnes Stores premises on Honan’s Quay is part of the college’s property portfolio.
Prof Kilcommins said they are “seriously looking at the city centre”.
“Honan’s Quay has to be in the mix, but it may not necessarily mean a health sciences school would be there. It might be that Honan’s Quay needs to be disposed of as part of the appraisals process.
“If the appraisal comes back and it doesn’t support the city, then for the next number of years we are only going to be on campus.”
