‘Intolerable’ anti-social activity forces closure of historic Clonmel laneway

Clonmel Borough District has decided to extinguish the public right of way on East Lane, connecting Gladstone Street to Mitchell Street, because of persistent anti-social behaviourplaceholder image
Clonmel Borough District has decided to extinguish the public right of way on East Lane, connecting Gladstone Street to Mitchell Street, because of persistent anti-social behaviour | File Photo

Closure of laneway approved by Clonmel Borough District

The solution to anti-social behaviour in historic laneways in Clonmel was not the closure of the laneways but was down to policing, the November meeting of Clonmel Borough District was told.

Members of the authority decided to extinguish the public right of way at East Lane, Clonmel, with Cllr Pat English being the lone voice against the closure of the lane.

Cllr English argued that the issue was a policing matter and the laneway, which connects Gladstone Street and Mitchell Street, should not be closed as the public right of way existed for hundreds of years.

The meeting was told that business owners and property owners in the laneway had asked the authority to close the laneway because of persistent anti-social behaviour, drug-related activity, vandalism and damage to property. The meeting was also told that one business owner in the area had suffered a serious eye injury as a result of an incident in the laneway.

Cllr English said he was disappointed that the closure of the laneway was presented as a fait acompli at the meeting.

He said the public had a right of way there for hundreds of years, and he believed the public right of way should continue.

“I understand there is anti-social behaviour, but that is down to policing, and it should not be an excuse to close this lane, and I am opposing the closure of this lane,” said Cllr English.

Cllr English said anti-social behaviour in the town was down to policing and said there was a lack of Garda resources in the town.

“I am asking the members to oppose the closure of the lane because it has a rich history. If we have to close down historic lanes, we will have none left. It is all down to policing,” insisted Cllr English.

Mayor Cllr Siobhan Ambrose said that while she was not in favour of closing laneways in the town, she was supporting this move because of the huge difficulties being faced by business and property owners there.

Cllr Ambrose said one business owner had suffered permanent damage to his eyesight as a result of an incident in the lane; there was constant drug dealing in the laneway,a firework was thrown and individuals were climbing onto roofs and running across the roofs.

“You cannot have a Garda standing in a laneway 24/7,” said Cllr Ambrose.

Cllr Ambrose said the situation was becoming intolerable for business owners now. She was not in favour of closing all lanes in the town but was supporting the business owners given the circumstances in this case.

Cllr Ambrose said they wanted people to continue in business in the town and said that the personal safety of business and property owners was under threat.

Cllr Tom Acheson asked if the public used the laneway on a regular basis. He presumed that the people who needed access to the laneway would get it.

Gillian Flynn, District Engineer, said the property owners in the laneway had approached her looking for a solution to the issue.A number of measures had been used to try and combat the anti-social behaviour, such as trying to encourage more footfall in the laneway, but anti-social behaviour continued, and she was aware that one property owner had sustained permanent damage to his eye as a result of anti-social behaviour.

She said a survey was carried out among property owners and they were all in favour of closing the lane. There would be an automated locking system installed in the gates at either end of the laneway. Anybody using the laneway would be granted access; it would be authorised access only.

Cllr Richie Molloy said there had been a number of incidents in the laneway.

“We have to face the facts,” said Cllr Molloy.

Cllr Molloy said that the authority had previously closed a lane in the town that, on review, was opened up again years later.

He suggested that the same could happen in relation to the East Lane and the matter could be reviewed at a later date.

“I am supporting closing it now, and it can be revisited in a few years time. At this moment, people are in dread of going down there. I would be anxious about going down there now, said Cllr Molloy.

Cllr John Fitzgerald said this lane was not like other lanes in the town, as there was not a constant flow of people in and out of the lane.

“This place is different as it is harbouring quite a bit of devilment,” said Cllr Fitzgerald. He believed that closing the laneway would flush out the anti-social element onto the streets and the Gardaí would be able to see what was happening.

He said the business people wanted the matter to be under control and he believed that not many members of the public were using the laneway.

Cllr Ambrose proposed the extinguishment of the public right of way, and Cllr Fitzgerald seconded the proposal. Cllr English was the only dissenting voice.

Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice