Final hours of Kildare killer’s life revealed in report

John Crerar placeholder image
John Crerar | (File Photo / RTE)

Kildare town native John Crerar was convicted of the 1979 murder of 23-year-old Phyllis Murphy

By Darragh Mc Donagh

A man who was serving a life sentence for murdering a Kildare woman did not apply for compassionate temporary release before his death in hospital last year, despite knowing that his life expectancy was short, an investigation has revealed.

John Crerar, who was convicted of the 1979 murder of 23-year-old Phyllis Murphy, died at the Mater Misericordiae Hospital in Dublin on January 25, 2025, aged 76.

He is not named in the report by the Office of the Inspector of Prisons (OIP), which was published on Friday.

The OIP found no failings in the care provided to Crerar at Arbour Hill and made no recommendations.

However, investigators noted that while both the Irish Prison Service (IPS) and Crerar were aware that his life expectancy was short, no application was made for compassionate temporary release.

Crerar had been jailed for life in 2002 after DNA breakthroughs linked a voluntary blood sample he gave gardaí in 1980 to the abduction and murder of Ms Murphy, who disappeared in Kildare in December 1979.

According to the OIP report, Crerar suffered from stage four chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD), as well as heart and urology complications, and required oxygen tanks and a concentrator.

Due to his declining health, he was housed in an adapted single cell on a smoke-free landing. His care needs increased significantly during the final six months of his life, requiring two or more admissions to the Mater Hospital.

At around 3am on January 24, routine cell checks found Crerar in severe respiratory distress.

Nursing staff attended immediately, and by 5am a nurse noted that he was experiencing “end of life symptoms”.

An emergency discharge to hospital was requested at 6.15am following a delay in which staff had to coax Crerar into agreeing to go to the Mater Hospital.

A Dublin Fire Brigade ambulance arrived at the prison at 6.36am and departed with him at 7am.

Crerar’s condition continued to deteriorate in hospital, where his sister and one of his children remained at his bedside until he died at approximately 2pm on Saturday, January 25.

The report noted that Crerar had been estranged from most of his family and had received no recent prison visits, though he maintained daily phone contact with his sister and a friend.

In written correspondence with the OIP in July 2025, Crerar’s sister stated that the family had no concerns about his treatment, adding that he “was content and happy to serve his time in Arbour Hill” and had been “treated with great care and kindness”.

Following a critical incident review meeting on January 30, 2025, prison management praised staff for their diligence and discussed potential internal actions, including issuing life alert devices to frail prisoners.

Related topics:
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice