Call for ‘assisted living’ measures over assisted dying in Ireland

As Ireland prepares for a pivotal vote on the ‘Assisted Dying Bill’ on October 17, the debate surrounding life, autonomy, and societal responsibility has intensified. The proposed legislation, which aims to allow assisted dying and euthanasia under strict guidelines, has drawn sharp criticism from Aontú candidate Graham Monaghan.

Monaghan, who is running for the Sligo-Leitrim-South Donegal constituency, questions the motivations behind this legislative push. He asks whether it’s a cost-cutting measure that implies only the strongest should have the right to life. “Are we losing our moral compass?” he queries, highlighting the danger of treating those facing hardships as second-class citizens.

Opposition to the bill is echoed by both the Irish Association of Palliative Care and the Royal College of Physicians. Dr. Theo Boer, a former advocate for assisted dying in the Netherlands, revealed alarming trends, noting that assisted suicide cases in his country have quadrupled over two decades. This raises concerns about expanding qualifying categories and diminishing safeguards, leading to vulnerable populations feeling pressured to end their lives.

Monaghan cautions against the ‘slippery slope’ effect seen in countries like Belgium and Canada, where euthanasia laws have broadened to include mental health issues and other vulnerable groups. He questions how the government can guarantee the safety of these individuals if it struggles to impose strict conditions.

Aontú stands alone in the Dáil in opposing measures perceived as disconnected from public sentiment. In recent referendums, the government faced overwhelming rejection from the public, with Aontú advocating for life-affirming measures instead. Monaghan emphasizes the importance of compassionate care, citing the invaluable support of local facilities like the North West Hospice.

In closing, Monaghan urges the public to reject the Assisted Dying Bill, advocating for ‘assisted living’ measures that promote dignity and support for all. “Let’s learn from the mistakes of other countries,” he implores, calling for active opposition to the proposed legislation.