Council was warned that Brexit could derail European Capital of Culture bid


by Gareth Cross
Derry and Belfast's councils ploughed ahead with their £350,000 European Capital of Culture 2023 campaign despite private concerns that Brexit would derail the bid, it emerged last week.
Internal correspondence released last week shows that the councils asked the British government if the bid could be jeopardised by the Brexit vote. And they were warned that it could - and that the government was not prepared to cover their losses.
The European Commission (EC) announced in November that all bids for the title from the United Kingdom, including Belfast-Derry would be immediately discontinued due to Brexit.
The two councils had already spent £350,000 on their joint bid by the time it was announced that they were no longer eligible.
According to the European Commission, the European Capitals of Culture initiative, which began in 1985, is designed to 'highlight the richness and diversity of cultures in Europe', adding that its experience has shown that event is an excellent opportunity for ‘regenerating cities, raising the international profile of cities, boosting tourism and breathing new life into a city's culture’.
In July the two councils sent a joint letter to the Department for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport (DCMS) to seek assurances the bid could still go-ahead. This information has come to light as the result of a Freedom of Information request.
The letter from Derry City and Strabane District Council Chief Executive John Kelpie and Belfast City Council Chief Executive Suzanne Wylie asked the department to "provide an up-to-date position on the 2023 designation in the context of Brexit negotiations."
They asked for the update "given the level of financial commitment involved in bidding as well as significant engagement with local citizens."
"In particular, has a formal agreement been reached with the European Commission that the UK city designated as European Capital of Culture 2023 will be accepted by the EU regardless of the outcome of these negotiations?" the letter asked.
In response the DCMS said the competition would "run as normal" but warned the councils that Brexit negotiations "could have a bearing on the UK's participation and the government will advise on this once negotiations have been concluded".
"As is usual with cultural programmes and competitions the UK government bears no responsibility for the financial investment made by cities and councils," the department said.
After the EC confirmed the bid could not go ahead, a spokesperson for the local council said that, Derry City and Strabane District Council and Belfast City Council have spent a total of £350,000 to date out of the total budget of £800,000.
However, the spokesperson did not say how much Derry City and Strabane District Council had contributed to the £350,000 spend.
'Bit of a gamble'
In April, SDLP councillor Shauna Cusack admitted at a Derry City and Strabane District meeting that while the bid was 'highly ambitious', it was also a 'bit of a gamble'.
The meeting was told that there were ‘multiple risks’ associated with Derry/Belfast bid, many of which could be managed by both the councils.
However, Oonagh McGillion, Director of Legacy with the council, said that the key risk of the bid being cancelled due to the UK no longer being part of the EU due to Brexit was ‘beyond the control’ of the council.
She added that Department for Culture, Media and Sport (DCMS) could not give a commitment at this stage due to ongoing Brexit negotiations and the department had ‘made it clear that all financial and resource investment, by a bidding city/region, is undertaken at risk’.
A spokesperson for Derry City and Strabane District Council said that the five bidding cities are continuing to liaise with the Department for Culture Media and Sport on the status of the ECoC 2023 competition and to agree a clear way forward for all the cities involved.
"Derry City and Strabane District Council and Belfast City Council remain committed to this process and will communicate any further developments once they become available," the spokesperson said.