Council's £300,000 bid for Euro culture title described as a 'bit of a gamble'

placeholder image

A Derry councillor has admitted that a decision to allocate £300,000 of ratepayers’ money on a bid for the city to become the 2023 European Capital of Culture is a ‘bit of a gamble’.

The decision to allocate the money came at Tuesday’s meeting of Derry City and Strabane District Council, where approval was given to allocate the money as part of a joint bid with Belfast City Council to be the European Capital of Culture in 2023.

Belfast City Council is allocating £500,000 to the bid, which must be submitted before October 27, 2017.

According to the European Commission, the European Capitals of Culture initiative, which began in 1985, is designed to ’highlight the richness and diversity of cultures in Europe’, adding that its experience has shown that event is an excellent opportunity for ‘regenerating cities, raising the international profile of cities, boosting tourism and breathing new life into a city's culture’.

A call is issued six years prior to the title being award for submissions, after which the submitted applications are reviewed by panel of independent experts in the field of culture, who draw up a short-list of cities, which are then asked to submit more detailed applications.

The panel then reconvenes to assess the final applications and recommends one city per host country for the title. The recommended city will then be formally designated as European Capital of Culture.

The city is formally designated four years before the actual year to allow it to prepare for the event.

The current 2017 European Capitals of Culture are Aarhus in Denmark and Pafos in Cyprus.

The meeting was told that there were ‘multiple risks’ associated with Derry/Belfast bid, many of which could be managed by both the councils.

However, Oonagh McGillion, Director of Legacy with the council, said that the key risk of the bid being cancelled due to the UK no longer being part of the EU due to Brexit was ‘beyond the control’ of the council.

She added that Department for Culture, Media and Sport (DCMS) could not give a commitment at this stage due to ongoing Brexit negotiations and the department had ‘made it clear that all financial and resource investment, by a bidding city/region, is undertaken at risk’.

The meeting was also told that the DCMS will not reimburse any cost involved if the bid is ruled to be ineligible.

It also emerged that another major risk is the lack of a functioning NI Executive and the ‘potential for a lack of political support for the bid’, with Ms McGillion advising that the Executive is left out of the first phase of the bid and that council instead approach the NI Office to ‘obtain formal government backing’.

She also said that a further risk could the ‘eligibility’ of the two-city approach, but that the most recent European Capital of Culture had a three city approach, called the ‘Three Sisters’, which included the cities of Waterford, Killkenny and Wexford, and progressed to stage two of the process but was ultimately unsuccessful to Galway.

Ms McGillion added ‘notwithstanding the importance of the title’, the ‘collaborative process of the joint bid will strengthen the position of the two councils and offer an opportunity to develop a cultural programme for 2023 with the potential of central government support’.

She continued that ‘a strong brand’ for the joint city bid naming both cities as either the Belfast Derry bid or the Derry Belfast bid was ‘critical to the success of the bid’.

Ms McGillion ended by quoting one of the judges, Bob Palmer who described the bidding process as ‘not being for the faint hearted’, but added that it could have a ‘huge transformational impact’ on the cities involved.

The chair of the committee, the SDLP’s Shauna Cusack, said that while it was ‘a hugely ambitious project’, the bid was a ‘bit of a gamble’.

“There’s a lot of pros and a lot of cons, we could be winners, we could be losers, but we need to focus on what we’re going to get out of this,” she continued, before adding, “it’s a bit of a gamble I’m afraid.”

Sinn Fein’s Michael Cooper said that if successful, the title would ‘exceed’ that of the City of Culture in 2013, adding that he was ‘very happy to pursue measures to protect the bid’.

Cllr Cooper added that the bid was ‘worth pursuing notwithstanding’ the impact of Brexit and the absence of an Executive, and proposed that the bid go ahead.

The DUP’s David Ramsey said that while the issue was a ‘no-brainer’, it was important that council got the branding right, and that ‘Londonderry’ was included in the bid title.

“If this is successful, it will open area up, but we need to get the branding right from the start,” he added.

Cllr Cooper said that any discussion on that issue would be ‘extremely premature’.

The UUP’s Derek Hussey said he was ‘sceptical’ of the bid, given that there had been no ‘definitive answer’ on whether the bid would still be eligible post Brexit.

Alderman Hussey continued that even if the bid was successful, he failed to see how Derry and Strabane would benefit from partnering with Belfast, adding that while people may travel to the northwest for events, they would stay in Belfast due to the number of hotels available.

“Is it a worthwhile risk?” he added, before asking how much it would have cost Derry to launch the bid without Belfast, with Mrs McGillion responding that it would have been an extra £200,000, meaning a total of £500,000.

In regards to Alderman Ramsey’s comments, she said that different branding options could be explored, but ‘for the purpose of the bid’ it would be better to keep it to just Derry and Belfast, as the judges ‘didn’t know about multiple names for the area’.

The SDLP’s John Boyle said that the discussion of branding ‘should come further down the line’, adding that while there were ‘so many unknowns we have to start somewhere’, and seconded Cllr Coopers’s proposal.

The chair, Cllr Cusack, asked if the councillors present were happy to support the issue, at which pointy the DUP’s Graham Warke attempted to speak on the branding issue, but was cut off by the chair Shaun, who said that she was ‘shutting down’ the discussion.

The UUP’s Derek Hussey then addressed Cllr Cusack: “You’ve asked if everyone is content, and someone isn’t, and you’re not going to let them in?”

Alderman Ramsey then asked if council could guarantee that ‘Londonderry’ would be used on the bid, with Cllr Cusack replying that they weren’t having the ‘argument about the city’s name again’.

Councillors then approved the bid going ahead.

Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice