Sideline View - Clubs need to grasp the nettle


“The difference between winning a club and a county All-Ireland is when you get a slap on the back after the match, you actually know the person when you turn around.”
Tomás Meehan – Caltra
THE Meehans of Caltra stepped into folklore on St Patrick’s Day 2004 as they landed the biggest prize in club GAA. Michael scored 0-6, skipper Noel scored 0-5, Enda was full back, Declan Meehan played wing back but it was the statement from Tomás that summed it up for me.
Meehan won ‘Sam’ twice with Galway but when he helped Caltra realise the dream – he knew those patting him on the back. The club championship has that unrivalled appeal.
Sunday week ago Cloughmills celebrated in the fog at the foot of Slemish after securing an Ulster title. Weeks before that was the sheer elation when Slaughtneil won their first ever Ulster Camogie title after an epic comeback.
I remember the scenes when Adrian McGuckin carried the Andy Merrigan Cup over Ballinderry Bridge in 2002 and buzz in the parish hall afterwards. The ultimate warrior Gavin Conwell carrying the Ulster title into Farah’s as Craigbane won a second Ulster title back in 2011. Heroes returning with the spoils of battle.
I played in a UUJ Fresher team with Joe Cassidy, Gareth Doherty, John McEntee and Cathal Short. Despite the Bellaghy/Cross rivalry, the four of them lived out of each other’s pockets in Belfast’s student haven. I was envious of their success - there was just something special about it.
It makes me realise how momentous GAA President Sean Kelly’s decision was - to introduce the Intermediate and Junior All-Ireland club championships. Everyone is equal and regardless of grade, county champions have the opportunity to grace Croke Park.
With the floodlights now knocked off for the winter, the GAA hierarchy takes centre stage. Dinner dances and AGMs will dominate the landscape but the association is facing the biggest decision yet.
Only 0.5% of the playing population play in county panels but for the rest –- they are crying out for respect.
Most club players now are training twice a week as a group, following a gym programme and attending video analysis meetings. But it’s a regular programme of games everyone is craving.
Last year, Brian Smith entrusted Stephen Barker to lead a root and branch study of club activity. It was a great call as Barker, a current player, was in touch with the needs of clubs.
The leagues ran off without a hitch but the introduction of a two week holiday period - that was the ace card. For once, the club player had a structure to the summer months. Family time could be planned and holidays could be booked – a factor that cannot be under-estimated.
THE CPA
On January 9th 2017 the new Club Players Association will be launched. We have let the fixture issue spiral out of control and as Declan Brennan outlined over the weekend, he wants clubs and players to take ownership now.
He is right the club is too important. I was at our club Big Breakfast, brilliantly organised and supported I must add, on Saturday.
Standing behind me in the queue was Patsy Bradley, one of the club’s most iconic players - as modest as ever. That’s the beauty of our association, the heroes from battles on a Sunday mingle freely with everyone else – no egos, no airs or graces.
The club is the heartbeat and so it should be. We hear it often enough from high ranking officials at dinner dances and functions. The sad fact of the matter is that it is not. Clubs are second class citizens and at a time when the club scene has never been more popular.
“The last seven or eight years – the whole structure of the system has been to the detriment of the club players,” stated Brennan. “I feel it is in everybody’s head but I felt I’d speak about it to see could we do something about it.”
Brennan outlined three motions that have been tabled by clubs in different provinces.
CPA Proposals
(1) Firstly, rule 3.58 in the 2016 Official Guide ‘recognises’ the GPA as the official representative of inter-county players. The motion aims to get the CPA added here.
(2) Any inter-county player not featuring in a ‘cumulative total’ of 30 minutes across three consecutive inter-county competitive games, shall be available ‘without prejudice’ for their club’s next game.
(3) Amendment to section 7.2 of the Club Constitution to allow 2 players on the club executive committee. It currently sits at one player.
NEED FOR CHANGE
I remember Swatragh and Lavey playing a county final on Boxing Day 1993, players with cut knees on the frozen Glenullin pitch.
In the early 2000s Kevin Lynch’s had to play in Ulster 24 hours after an energy sapping extra time victory over Slaughtneil in the Derry Final. Cloughaneely doing likewise against Castledawson two years ago.
Other examples include the ongoing issue in Donegal with club fixtures put on the back burner to suit county preparation. Slaughtneil’s dual players playing 13 games in 12 weeks during the 2014 season. The same situation occurred in Munster with Cratloe.
The other side of the coin saw Ardboe and Eglish knocked of the senior championship on May 31st 2015, with no top flight games until August 2016. This year’s Tyrone minor club season was all but over ahead of the Ulster Minor championship in May – leaving young lads short-changed for the rest of the season.
Another common expression we often hear uttered – ‘the GAA need to do something about it’. Indeed they do but ‘we’ are the GAA – the membership.
The only way a ruling can change is at club level. Any gripes need proper thought, get your club to table a motion to the county board. Then the process begins with an eventual appearance at GAA Congress.
Speaking on a recent podcast, Crossmaglen’s Aaron Kernan was commenting about how his team mates were complaining about the lack of change. They didn’t attend the AGM – what do they expect?
That’s Declan Brennan’s point too and in January there will be an opportunity for club players to have a voice.
I sent my recommendations through to Declan’s email address ([email protected]). So too have around 100,000 others. Have you?
Perhaps there are those who won’t agree with the avenue the CPA are trying to take. It’s all about opinions but 95.5% of ‘non-county’ players deserve to have a better structured calendar.
Thankfully in Derry, we had Stephen Barker with his thinking cap on last year and he made a lot of friends by introducing a holiday window. It’s the kind of respect everyone is entitled to.