St Eunan’s exit Ulster following heartbreaking loss to Scotstown


The Letterkenny side went down on penalties at Brewster Park in the Ulster Club SFC semi-final following a controversial late leveller from Scotstown
Scotstown 1-24 St Eunan’s 0-27
Scotstown win 4-2 on penalties
SCOTSTOWN ran the gauntlet to reach the Ulster Club SFC final once again and leave St Eunan’s heartbroken in controversial circumstances at Brewster Park in Enniskillen.
The Donegal SFC winners from Letterkenny were fuming when a late free from Kieran Hughes was allowed to stand, to level the scores with 10 seconds of extra-time to play.
Kieran Donnelly’s players claimed it went wide of the post, which TV replays seeming to back up that claim. It was one of the closing acts in a pulsating contest.
From there, Scotstown drew on their experience and penalties in the shoot-out from Rory Beggan, Darren Hughes, Shaner Carey and Conor McCarthy saw them home.
St Eunan’s, against the wind, put themselves in a decent position towards the end of the first half, leading 0-7 to 0-4.
Goalkeeper Shaun Patton, who sadly lost his father, Peter, in the last fortnight, had brought a warm cheer for those clad in black and amber with a two-pointer.
Scotstown, the reigning Ulster champions, put the squeeze on things late in the half to complete a remarkable turnaround.
Conor McCarthy’s free and a score from Donnchadh Connolly brought the Monaghan team back to just one down.
Then, in injury time, a pair of stunning two-pointers from Tommy Mallen and then a vintage free from Beggan, from all of 65 metres, meant Scotstown were 0-10 to 0-7 in front at half-time.
St Eunan’s seemed to have been left at arm’s length in the second half. Driven on by the O’Donnell brothers, with Shane putting over two two-pointers and Niall one, they were never out of it.
But every time they came up with something, Scotstown had an answer and this point was emphasised with five minutes to play.
McCarthy ran right at the heart of the St Eunan’s defence and slipped off to Murray, who smashed between Patton’s legs with less than five to play. Scotstown were 1-17 to 0-17 ahead, and it looked like their experience was going to take them over the line.
St Eunan’s, though, dug in and Eoin Dowling smashed for goal only to see it whizz over the crossbar. Then, in the last of the four minutes of injury time and only seconds to play, Winston, with his team two down, hit a peach of a two to level things at 0-21 for St Eunan’s and 1-18 for Scotstown.
Carey’s free and a point from full-back Ryan O’Toole and another from Sherlock meant Scotstown settled much the better in extra-time with the wind at their backs once more.
However, St Eunan's went in just two down, with Niall O’Donnell scoring a free and having survived an impotent lob from Max Maguire coming back off their crossbar. At half-time in extra-time, Scotstown were 1-21 to 0-22 ahead.
Conor O’Donnell Snr and Kieran Hughes traded points in the second half of extra-time, but St Eunan’s again managed a magical two-pointer, this time from Brian MacIntyre to put them one in front.
However, after Kieran Hughes’ free at the other end was adjudged to have gone over the bar, Dylan Doogan missed a glorious chance to win it, only to skew wide.
Scotstown: Rory Beggan (0-2, 1tpf); Mark McCaffrey, Damien McArdle, Darragh Murray (1-0); Ryan O’Toole (0-1), Donnchadh Connolly (0-1), Conor McCarthy (0-5, 1tp, 1f); Micheál McCarville, Darren Hughes; Gavin McPhillips, Shane Carey (0-2, 2fs), Francis Maguire (0-1); Tommy Mallen (0-4, 1tp), Nicky Sherlock (0-3), Mattie Maguire (0-2). Subs: Max Maguire (0-1) for F.Maguire (47 mins), Kieran Hughes (0-2, 1f) for McPhillips (53 mins), Sean Óg McElwain for Mattie Maguire (55 mins), James Hamill for Connolly (63 mins), Mark McPhillips for Sherlock (68 mins), Jack McDevitt for McCaffrey (81 mins).
St Eunan’s: Shaun Patton (0-2, 1tp); Noah Barrett, Caolan Ward, Josh Hay; James Kelly, Kieran Tobin, Oran Winston (0-3, 1tp); James Kelly, Eoin Dowling (0-3, 1tpf), Ciaran Moore, Luke McGuinness (0-1), Conor O’Donnell Snr (0-1), Shane O’Donnell (0-4, 2tps); Eoin McGeehin (0-3), Niall O’Donnell (0-5, 1tp, 1f), Conor O’Donnell Jnr (0-3, 1f 1 ‘45’). Subs: Dylan Doogan for McGeehin (61 mins), Brian MacIntyre (0-2, 1tp) for Hay (68 mins), Padraig McGettigan and Evan Daly for C.O’Donnell Jnr and Barrett (71 mins).
Referee: Kieran Eannetta (Tyrone).
Scotstown scorers: Conor McCarthy 0-5, tp, 1f; Tommy Mallen 0-4, tp; Nicky Sherlock 0-3; Darragh Murray 1-0; Mattie Maguire 0-2; Shane Carey 0-2, 2f; Donnchadh Connolly, Francis Maguire, Max Maguire, Ryan O’Toole and Kieran Hughes 0-1, 1f.
St Eunan’s scorers: Niall O’Donnell 0-5, tp; Shane O’Donnell 0-4, 2tp; Conor O’Donnell Jnr 0-3, 45, 1f; Eoin McGeehin 0-3; Oran Winston 0-3, tp; Eoin Dowling 0-3, tp; Shaun Patton 0-2, 2pf; 1f; Brian MacIntyre 0-2, tp; Luke McGuinness and Conor O’Donnell Snr 0-1.
Scotstown: Rory Beggan; Mark McCaffrey, Ryan O’Toole, Darragh Murray; Donnchadh Connolly, Damien McArdle, Conor McCarthy; Micheál McCarville, Darren Hughes; Gavin McPhillips, Shane Carey, Francis Maguire; Tommy Mallen, Nicky Sherlock, Matthew Maguire. Subs: Max Maguire for F Maguire 47; Kieran Hughes for G McPhillips 53; Sean Óg Elwain for Mattie Maguire (55); Jamie Hamill for Connolly (60+3); Mark McPhillips for Sherlock (68); Jack McDevitt for
St Eunan’s: Shaun Patton; Noah Barrett, Caolan Ward, Josh Hay; Kieran Tobin, Conor O’Donnell Snr, Oran Winston; James Kelly, Eoin Dowling; Ciaran Moore, Shane O’Donnell, Luke McGuinness, Eoin McGeehin, Niall O’Donnell, Conor O’Donnell Jnr. Subs: Dylan Doogan for McGeehin (60); Brian MacIntyre for Hay (68); Pauric McGettigan and Evan Daly for O’Donnell Jnr and Barrett (half-time, extra-time)
Referee: Kieran Eannetta (Tyrone)
