Victim collided with lorry after night at hospital beside sick mother


Donegal coroner’s inquest occurs into the passing of Moville’s Mary Whitters Borland who died in a traffic collision on the R238 in September 2023
A tragic accident in Moville resulting in the death of the driver, 59-year-old Mary Whitters Borland, who collided with an oncoming lorry, occurred after she had spent the night at her mother’s bedside in hospital.
Donegal coroner, Dr Denis McCauley, said at the inquest into Ms Whitters Borland’s passing, held on Wednesday, November 18, at Letterkenny Courthouse, that Ms Whitters Borland “died of injuries as a result of a road collision.”
Ms Whitters Borland was the driver of a Suzuki SX4 that collided with a Volvo lorry that was returning to Omagh, Tyrone, from Greencastle, on the R238 in Moville on September 22, 2023.
The Coroner’s Court heard that the night previous, Mary had “sat in the chair with her mother overnight” at a Donegal hospital.
The deposition of Michael McLaughlin, a witness who was driving behind Ms Whitters Borland at the incident, said: “I was travelling from Quigley’s Point to Shrove in the far side of Greencastle.
“I remember driving behind two cars, both of them driving normal.
“I remember driving along at the wall of the community school.
“There is a footpath and the road is very narrow.
“I saw the car at the last second cross over the white line and crash into the oncoming lorry.”
McLaughlin described the collision as “horrific.”
He continued: “I didn’t have to brake suddenly, nor did the woman in front of me; that was how slow we were going.
“The lorry driver got out. He was in total shock. He would weep quietly for a minute and then say there was nothing he could do. That was true; there was nothing he could do.”
Dr McCauley asked if Ms Whitters Borland’s vehicle glided across the road, or was moved more suddenly, to which McLaughlin replied: “Suddenly.”
Raymond Conway, who was the driver of the lorry driver, said he was delivering stone to Greencastle from Omagh, and was returning home on his journey.
He said he would not have known the road, but had become familiar with the road after a few months.
The deposition stated: “There was not much traffic out on the road.
“All of the sudden, the car came out into my side of the lane. I can not say how long exactly, but it was just a blank.
“They were flat. They were laying over at 45 degrees.
“I would say half or more of the car impacted the lorry. I went off and hit the ditch on the left side.
“The truck was lying down on the left-hand side, but I was able to take my seat belt out.
“I could not face looking into the car.
“There was debris all over the road.
“They took me into Letterkenny Hospital. I was in the hospital for about two hours.”
Conway’s deposition said that after the collision occurred, there was “no noise whatsoever, just silence.”
Dr McCauley asked Conway if he had time to react to brake. Conway replied: “It was a second.”
“Mary had an abnormal angle in the car,” said Dr McCauley.
Ms Whitters Borland’s husband, Mark Borland, told Dr McCauley that Ms Whitters Borland “would have been in the hospital with her mum” and that “Mary was well used to being in hospital and sleeping in the chair.”
Dr McCauley said: “It was an abnormal evening for her since she had spent the night with her mum. It was not a planned thing. It was an emergency.”
Garda Sergeant Emmett Brady, of Buncrana Garda Station, told the Coroner’s Court: “I spoke to the nurse, who said Mary had sat in the chair with her mother overnight. She did recall Mary being at the bedside with her mother overnight.”
A Senior Forensics Collision Investigator, Garda Gerard McCauley, said that “there was no evidence to suggest that speed had a part to play for either party.
He stated: “The lorry driver reacted early and aggressively. He was also under heavy braking.”
In his summary, Dr McCauley commented: “We have a good understanding.
“For some reason, Mary became distracted, and the probability is that people tend to relax when they are nearly finished.
“Mary had an abnormal angle in the car; the level of proof was more likely than not.
“Her mum was sick and stayed in hospital. She was coming home and, from a short distance from home, her attention dropped because she unfortunately drifted for a second, and during that second, unfortunately, hit the lorry.
“Mary died of injuries as a result of a road collision.
“Unfortunately, we have, at one stage, drifted and have been able to respond when it happened, but due to the bad luck, she was not able to.”
