Late-night row and garda pepper spray led to contested hearing in Leitrim court

Carrick-on-Shannon District Court heard sharply contested evidence on April 22 in an assualt charge case against David Fox (50), of Halls, Gorvagh, Leitrim, arising from a late-night public order incident at the family home in the early hours of April 28, 2025.

Mr Fox denied the charges and contested the matter, while his wife Andrea Fox (50), also of Halls, Gorvagh, gave evidence on his behalf. Separate no insurance/failure to produce matters involving Andrea Fox were also brought before the court.

David Fox faced charges of intoxication in a public place, threatening, abusive or insulting behaviour in a public place, and obstructing a peace officer. Garda Sean Murphy told the court he had been investigating an earlier material damage road traffic collision involving the Foxes’ son, Connor, when he went to the family home shortly after 2am.

He said he met Andrea Fox reversing a vehicle at the end of the driveway where it met the public road. Garda Murphy said he informed her he was concerned for her son’s welfare and wished to speak with him in relation to the earlier collision.

Defence solicitor Colm Conway said it was the Fox family case that Garda Murphy had instead accused them of wrongdoing, putting it to the witness that he had said: “You are harbouring criminals.” Garda Murphy denied that account and said he was carrying out routine enquiries. He also told the court he was making a lawful demand regarding insurance connected to another vehicle. According to Garda Murphy, David Fox then exited the passenger side of the vehicle, became aggressive and began shouting abuse.

He said Mr Fox called Gardaí “government debt collecting wankers” and “a shower of c**ts.”Garda Murphy further alleged Mr Fox clenched his fists, adopted a fighting stance and moved towards Gardaí in an aggressive manner.

READ MORE: GPs voice concerns about introduction of paid parking at Flynn's Field car park

He said Garda Tansey then deployed pepper spray before Mr Fox was restrained and arrested. The court heard Garda Murphy said Mr Fox continued to behave aggressively while being transported to Carrick-on-Shannon Garda Station, striking his head off the patrol car window. Garda Tansey gave similar evidence.

He told the court Mr Fox shouted at Gardaí to “get to f**k off my property.” He said after being informed he was under arrest, Mr Fox replied: “It’ll take more than the three of ye to take me.” Garda Tansey said Mr Fox raised clenched fists and attempted to strike Gardaí, at which point pepper spray was used.He said he did not use the spray lightly and only did so because he believed it was necessary in the circumstances. The member in charge at Carrick-on-Shannon Garda Station said Mr Fox arrived highly intoxicated, aggressive and unsteady on his feet, and had to be brought directly to a cell for safety reasons.

Mr Conway argued the central issue in the case was location. He submitted that the prosecution had failed to prove beyond reasonable doubt that the alleged offences occurred in a public place, a necessary element of the charges before the court. Mr Conway said: “That is the crux of the matter.” He said Garda evidence regarding the exact location was “less than satisfactory” and argued the matter only became clearly described as a public place after prompting during the hearing. He further submitted Garda Murphy had no business being on the property and suggested he had effectively been waiting in darkness before the Foxes reversed down the driveway.

Mr Conway said it was the defence case that Garda Murphy had “stepped out of the trees” as the couple were leaving the house. He also criticised the use of pepper spray, saying the court had heard evidence that intoxication combined with pepper spray could lead to distress and disorientation. Andrea Fox told the court she was reversing down the driveway when she saw a flashlight and realised a Garda was present. She said the conversation was initially civil but became heated when Gardaí accused the family of “harbouring a criminal.”Mrs Fox denied her husband had acted violently and said he struck the boot of the car in frustration but did not throw punches.She claimed he was pepper sprayed from close range, taken to the ground and dragged to the patrol car.David Fox admitted consuming alcohol that night and accepted he had used bad language.Under questioning, he said he had consumed four hot whiskies at the house before leaving.When asked about the size of the drinks, he said he was unsure, prompting the prosecution to put it to him: “So around ten measures of alcohol?” Mr Fox replied that he was not certain of the quantities.He told the court: “I’m not disputing anything that I said.”However, he denied acting violently and said he had turned away when Gardaí moved on him. He said he was in “excruciating pain” after being sprayed. The prosecution also challenged how, after consuming that amount of alcohol, he could be so certain about the exact location of the incident. Mr Fox said he knew the driveway well and remained adamant about where the confrontation occurred. He also told the court he had contested the matter because of concerns over the renewal of his firearms licences. After hearing submissions, Judge Éiteáin Cunningham said she was satisfied the prosecution had proven the case beyond reasonable doubt. She said: “I am satisfied that the incident occurred in a public place and in this regard both Gardaí were consistent with regard to the location.”

Judge Cunningham said she did not accept the suggestion Garda Murphy had been carrying out surveillance.She added: “I accept that he was present in the context of an ongoing investigation.”The judge also accepted Garda evidence that Mr Fox’s demeanour was aggressive and that the use of pepper spray was justified. She said she noted Garda Tansey’s evidence that Mr Fox’s behaviour existed “both prior to and after the use of pepper spray.” Judge Cunningham convicted Mr Fox and imposed a €500 fine.