Teen who died after altercation outside bar ‘never known to have any arguments’

Fionntán McGarvey inquestplaceholder image
Fionntán McGarvey inquest

Coroner Louisa Fee is set consider evidence around Fionntán McGarvey’s death following an inquest at Belfast Coroner’s Court.

A Belfast teenager who died following an altercation outside a bar has been described as someone who was never known to have any arguments, an inquest has heard.

Fionntán McGarvey, 18, died in hospital on January 20 2022, around three weeks after the incident outside the Devenish complex in the city in the early hours of December 27 2021.

An inquest into his death at Belfast Coroner’s Court heard evidence from police, medical experts and witnesses over four days.

Coroner Louisa Fee has indicated she will take some time to consider her findings in the case, and paid tribute to the dignity and courage of Mr McGarvey’s parents who attended each day of proceedings.

The 18-year-old, who was a talented sportsman, sustained a fractured skull and blood clot on the surface of his brain.

He was discharged from hospital eight days after the incident but suffered a bleed on the brain a week later.

His condition rapidly deteriorated and he died in hospital 24 days after the initial altercation.

On the first day of the inquest, Ms Fee heard from several witnesses who were outside the bar when Mr McGarvey was struck by Conor Erskine, whom he had known from school, after a verbal exchange.

On Wednesday, Mr Erskine gave evidence to the inquest, appearing by videolink from Australia.

He claimed he had acted in self defence, “swiping” Mr McGarvey which knocked him to the ground, after he contended he had threatened him.

On Thursday, expert witness neurosurgeon Ian Pople, who reviewed Mr McGarvey’s medical records, described the teenager as having suffered a “very nasty fracture” to the back part of his skull.

placeholder image

“If it affects the back part of the skull, the force must have been very severe, because it’s very thick bone at the back,” he said, adding there was bruising to the brain and swelling.

“That happens when the head has been forcibly hit against a hard subject or it’s decelerated very quickly, for instance in a road traffic accident where it stops suddenly.”

Dr Pople concluded that Mr McGarvey “suffered a moderately severe head injury, the result of the fall backwards on to concrete following the punch to the head”.

The inquest has not heard any theories for the tension between the two men.

A number of short statements were also read to the inquest on Thursday, including an account from a police officer who had spoken to Sophie Boyle, a friend of Mr McGarvey’s.

Ms Boyle described him as a “genuine guy, always nice, would give you a big hug, a friendly nice guy who would always make sure you were ok”.

“She had never known him to have any arguments… that night she would say that Fionntán was drinking but was the same level of drunk as everyone else in their friendship group,” the detective constable said.

“There were never any issues with Fionntán when he was drunk, and she would see him quite often…

“Sophie states what happened that night was a shock, she felt that Fionntán must have been hit as she would never imagine he would hit anyone – he was not that type of guy.”

Ms Fee said she intends to “take some time to consider all of the evidence that I have heard throughout this week before I come to my findings”.

“That’s likely to take some time,” she said.

Addressing Mr McGarvey’s parents, she added: “I would like to offer you both and your family my very serious condolences on the loss of Fionntán, and I appreciate what a difficult week this has been for you and your family, and I want to acknowledge yet again the dignity and courage you have shown throughout.”

Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice