Councils should not be ‘branch offices’ of Scottish Government, Alexander says


The Scottish Secretary accused ministers at Holyrood of ‘hoarding’ powers when he addressed local council leaders.
Holyrood ministers have been challenged to hand more powers to local communities, with Scottish Secretary Douglas Alexander insisting councils “should not be branch offices” of the Scottish Government.
The UK Government minister said that for the 19 years the SNP has been in power, “the motto has been that Holyrood knows best”, as he also complained funding has been “squeezed” from local authorities.
His comments came after First Minister John Swinney told council leaders gathered for local government body Cosla’s annual conference that his programme of public service reform – including a major shake-up of Scotland’s councils – could help “build stronger communities”.
But Mr Alexander told the conference in St Andrews that SNP ministers are “hoarding” power rather than passing them on to local communities.
He said council tax freezes from the Scottish Government mean the charge is “set all too often from the top”, while he complained much of the cash local government receive is ring-fenced.
The Scottish Secretary was clear that “councils aren’t and shouldn’t be branch offices of St Andrew’s House” – where the Scottish Government has its headquarters.
On funding, he said while the block grant the Scottish Government receives from Westminster has grown by “more than 20% in real-terms” since 2013, council funding has only increased 5% over the period.
Mr Alexander added: “If council funding had simply kept pace, Scotland’s councils would have around £2 billion more to spend each and every year.
“That is £2 billion that could be paying for schools, for social care, for roads and for housing.
“Let me be clear, the £2 billion gap isn’t the UK Government’s choice – it is a Scottish Government choice. These are choices made in Edinburgh.
“For 19 years seemingly the motto has been Holyrood knows best. It should be local knows best.
“Scotland deserves better than a Government forever demanding power from London, and then hoarding it from the communities across the country.”
Earlier, Cosla president Shona Morrison said Scotland “cannot reform our way” out of issues facing councils.
She stressed reforms to the public sector are “an opportunity to improve outcomes”, but said councils “still need a fair funding settlement to meet growing demand”.
Mr Swinney told council leaders gathered for the event that local and national governments are operating in an “age of remarkably constrained public finances”.
He said “global conflict and decisions made far beyond our shores” are impacting prices of energy, housing and everyday essentials in Scotland.
This, the First Minister said, creates an “incredibly challenging environment in which all public authorities are having to operate”.
However, he added: “If we are to build stronger communities, creating opportunity and restoring trust, we need public services that are able to do exactly that, and for that I believe we need public service reform.”
With the Scottish Government’s three-month period of consultation with councils and others over its planned reforms coming to an end, Mr Swinney said he was “grateful for the way Cosla and individual councils have engaged with my ministers and with me”.
The First Minister added: “We’ve given this all the pace and the urgency that this issue requires to agree a vision to get right to work, making that vision a reality.”