Whistleblower surgeon’s claim of avoidable deaths of ‘gravest concern’ – Swinney

External view of Aberdeen Royal Infirmaryplaceholder image
External view of Aberdeen Royal Infirmary

The First Minister was challenged after NHS Grampian surgeon Dr Mohammed Meed Habib called for the health board to face a corporate homicide probe.

Claims from an NHS whistleblower that 19 patients suffered an avoidable death while under the care of NHS Grampian are “of the gravest concern”, Scotland’s First Minister said.

John Swinney was speaking after Aberdeen Royal Infirmary surgeon Dr Mohammed Meer Habib claimed hundreds of patients may have suffered “significant harm or avoidable deaths” in recent years.

The consultant surgeon called for the health board to face a corporate homicide investigation – with this echoed by Labour leader and North East MSP Michael Marra.

Mr Marra told MSPs at Holyrood that NHS Grampian had “buried” the findings of a review it commissioned in 2022, looking at deaths amongst patients who underwent liver and pancreatic surgery.

He also said Dr Habib had written three times to the First Minister, and claimed Mr Swinney “did nothing”.

A senior Government source rejected those assertions, pointing to ministerial intervention in the board in recent years.

placeholder image

But with the Scottish Government stressing all correspondence from Dr Habib was responded to by officials, without being seen by ministers, it emerged that the First Minister has asked civil servants to consider if changes are required to this system.

It comes a week after a damning report by Healthcare Improvement Scotland found “serious weaknesses in all aspects of leadership and management of the medical workforce across the acute sector of NHS Grampian”.

Mr Swinney and Health Secretary Angela Constance both made clear improvements must be made in the wake of the report.

Raising the issue at First Minister’s Questions at Holyrood on Thursday, Mr Marra said the SNP leader had already been contacted by Dr Habib about his concerns.

“Four times Dr Habib wrote to Scottish ministers, three times to yourself, First Minister, seeking help for the people in his care,” Mr Marra said.

“Nothing was done to stop the deaths. Nothing.”

He said a review commissioned by NHS Grampian in 2022 had found that 19 deaths were “deemed to be avoidable and due to issues with their surgery”.

Lawyer Aamer Anwar, who represents Dr Habib, said in a statement: “The operation theatre he worked in at times could be described as a ‘slaughterhouse’, which killed through incompetence and negligence, whilst not giving a damn for accountability.”

Dr Habib said: “I know that today I am putting my career on the line to demand accountability and for the public to know the full extent of this cover-up.

“I believe that NHS Grampian should face an investigation for corporate homicide.”

Mr Marra backed that call, and also urged Permanent Secretary Joe Griffin, the Scottish Government’s most senior civil servant, to launch an urgent internal review into “who knew what and when in the Scottish Government”.

Mr Swinney said the issues raised by Dr Habib “are of the gravest of concern”, as he stressed patient safety must be “paramount” in the NHS.

However he made clear he could not force a criminal investigation into NHS Grampian.

placeholder image

The First Minister told MSPs: “When it comes to criminal prosecution, that is an issue that is not for me, I cannot direct the Lord Advocate to undertake that.

“It is for the police to consider any evidence and for the Lord Advocate and the Crown to make any judgments about the merits of a criminal prosecution.

“That is the action that must be undertaken by the appropriate authorities and it would be wrong for me to intervene in that process.”

Scottish Tory leader Russell Findlay also challenged Mr Swinney on the issue, saying Dr Habib had “exposed a deep-rooted culture of dishonesty and denial, of arrogance and incompetence, of industrial-scale cover-up”.

He too accused the First Minister of “ignoring” repeated warnings about Aberdeen Royal Infirmary, before asking Mr Swinney if he would be concerned about undergoing surgery at the hospital.

The First Minister told him: “I wouldn’t have concerns because we have clinical professionals who are undertaking good work in the National Health Service across the country.”

Speaking to journalists after First Minister’s Questions on Thursday, Mr Swinney said he wanted to foster an “open culture that we face up to where things go wrong within the National Health Service”, following allegations of whistleblowers being ignored in Glasgow and Tayside health boards.

“At all times, there has to be a culture of openness and as I’ve just said in the parliamentary chamber, let me reiterate it here – I attach the highest importance to ensuring that there is an open and transparent culture and there should be one in the National Health Service,” he said.

The First Minister added that Dr Habib has the protections afforded to whistleblowers.

In his statement, Dr Habib further alleged that two patients had died after they were given the wrong operation.

He formally raised concerns about “excessive mortality in surgery” in July 2021, claiming there were “dozens of avoidable deaths”.

placeholder image

The surgeon contacted Police Scotland about the deaths in 2024, and the following year wrote to the Lord Advocate.

The surgeon said he also contacted the First Minister and Health Secretary in June 2023, October 2024, November 2025 and May 2026, but was told the Scottish Government had no jurisdiction to investigate whistleblowing and individual boards.

Responding to the allegations, Laura Skaife-Knight, the chief executive of NHS Grampian, said: “We are aware of the serious allegations raised today.

“A thorough investigation has already taken place into these matters, with some elements of that work ongoing.

“Any new evidence or information will be carefully considered, and NHS Grampian will continue to respond through the appropriate clinical, governance and legal processes.

“We understand the allegations will cause further concern to patients, members of the public and staff.

“It is important we respect patient and employee confidentiality, but we can highlight that where reviews identify issues around patient care, the appropriate duty of candour processes are followed.

“This includes direct communication with patients and families where required.

“If our consideration of any new evidence identifies further individuals who should be contacted, we will do so. Patient safety remains our highest priority.”

Meanwhile a spokesperson for the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service (COPFS), said: “The concerns raised by Dr Habib were taken seriously by COPFS, with confirmation from Police Scotland that an inquiry was under way.

“Given the complexity and breadth of the issues raised, inquiries remain ongoing.”

Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice