Work to begin on A5 ‘as soon as we can’ after Appeal Court ruling, says Kimmins

Infrastructure Minister Liz Kimmins speaking to media outside the Court of Appeal in Belfastplaceholder image
Infrastructure Minister Liz Kimmins speaking to media outside the Court of Appeal in Belfast

Taoiseach Micheál Martin also welcomed the court ruling in Belfast.

Work on the delayed £1.7 billion A5 road upgrade should begin as soon as possible after the Court of Appeal quashed a ruling blocking the project, Infrastructure Minister Liz Kimmins has said.

Taoiseach Micheál Martin, whose government has pledged 600 million euro to the road, said he now looks forward to working with the Stormont Executive to deliver the major infrastructure scheme.

A previous High Court ruling that the project cannot proceed in its current form was overturned by a panel of Appeal Court judges, led by Lady Chief Justice Dame Siobhan Keegan.

placeholder image

The 58-mile proposed scheme, Northern Ireland’s largest ever road project, was given the green light by Stormont ministers in 2024.

However last year the High Court found the Department for Infrastructure’s (DfI) plans for the road did not comply with climate change targets, following a legal challenge from a group including residents, farmers and landowners.

Ms Kimmins then appealed against that ruling, stating she was determined to see the ambitious roads project completed.

The Infrastructure Minister, SDLP MLA Daniel McCrossan and campaigners were in court as the judgment was delivered on Tuesday.

Ms Kimmins said: “We knew that this day should come and we worked extremely hard to ensure that we brought a strong and robust case to the Appeal Court.

“We are delighted they took the time to carefully consider and come to the conclusion they have today.

“For me now the top priority is let’s get on with it, let’s get this road built, let’s save lives.”

The minister added: “This is my top priority.

“As soon as we are able to do so, we will be moving ahead.

placeholder image

“We will have to carefully consider the judgment.

“However, on all three grounds our appeal was won.

“For me, it is moving forward, and moving forward as quickly as possible to ensure we get work started as soon as we can.”

Mr Martin said: “Road safety is a key concern and too many lives have been lost in tragic circumstances along the A5 over the years.

“An upgraded road to the north-west will not only improve road safety but also bring economic and social benefits to people living along its route in Tyrone and Derry, and in connecting counties such as Monaghan and Donegal in particular.

“The government has made a funding commitment of 600 million euro to the A5 upgrade and that remains in place.

“The government looks forward now to continuing to work with the Executive to see the A5 upgrade finally delivered.”

In the Appeal Court, Dame Siobhan told the court that the litigation history around the project had been “long and tortuous”.

She pointed out that Stormont’s Department of Agriculture, Environment and Rural Affairs (Daera) had become involved in the case at the Court of Appeal stage and had filed new evidence.

She said: “Suffice to say the approach to this litigation adopted by the relevant departments has, in our view, been unsatisfactory and caused delay.

“Whilst we asked for an explanation as to how this came about, the response we received does not satisfy us that full thought was given to this case at the appropriate stages.”

The Lady Chief Justice said the court had to consider the appeal on three issues, environmental impact assessment (EIA) compliance, human rights obligations and compliance with climate change legislation.

Regarding EIA compliance, she said the High Court judge had “erred” in his analysis.

Dame Siobhan turned to consider the challenge on human rights grounds.

A number of people will lose land by the decision to turn the A5 into a dual carriageway due to vesting.

She said: “We find the argument based upon human rights to be unconvincing.

placeholder image

“The judge went too far and made assumptions he should not have made.”

The Appeal Court then turned to whether the proposed road project breached the obligations of the Climate Change Act passed in the Northern Ireland Assembly.

Dame Siobhan said the A5 project was “larger than any road project ever undertaken in Northern Ireland” and “inevitably this issue intersects with the Climate Change Act”.

She said: “We are satisfied that the legal obligations created by the 2022 Act to achieve net zero by 2050 is not a prohibition upon the authorisation for a new road where it has been assessed, as far as possible, to be consistent with emissions reduction obligations.”

Dame Siobhan said the High Court judge was “plainly wrong” to analyse a Climate Action Plan (CAP), an environmental strategy document produced by Daera.

She said: “He made an assessment that we consider was wrong, that there was insufficient evidence to satisfy climate obligations in the CAP because there was no specific mention of the A5.

“Properly analysed, this was a treacherous route for the judge to take without the benefit of submissions.”

placeholder image

The Lady Chief Justice said the court agreed with DfI submissions that the A5 project did not need to be specifically mentioned in the CAP.

She said: “That would stymie all major developments in Northern Ireland.”

Dame Siobhan said the only function of the court was to decide if the process taken by the decision-maker was lawful.

She added: “We are satisfied the DfI has, in making the decision to proceed with the A5 Western Transport Corridor, performed its function in a manner consistent with the obligations set out in the Act.”

Dame Siobhan said: “We allow the appeal and we set aside the order of the High Court quashing the decision to proceed with the A5 first phase on all grounds.

“We consider that the judge was wrong in his approach and the outcomes he reached in relation to the issues.”

There have been more than 50 deaths on the A5, which links Londonderry with Aughnacloy in Co Tyrone, since 2006.

A scheme to turn the road into a dual carriageway was first approved by the Executive in 2007, but it has been held up by legal challenges and uncertainty over funding ever since.

Speaking outside court, Niall McKenna, from the A5 Enough is Enough campaign group, said he felt pride for the families of those who had lost lives on the A5.

He said: “At times like this there is no feeling of celebration.

“Our campaign was all about saving lives. It was not to win court cases.”

He added: “My most pride is for the people who stand behind me, the families of victims of the A5, almost 60 in the 20 years since this road was supposed to have been delivered.

“It is too late for those people. Their loved ones are already gone.

“They have campaigned tirelessly to make sure that no other families have to suffer the pain that they have went through.”

Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice