Historic cup returned to Arranmore after more than three decades

Mark Sharkey and Seán Bonner presenting the cup to Noreen Muldowneyplaceholder image
Mark Sharkey and Seán Bonner presenting the cup to Noreen Muldowney | Seán Bonner

Written by Seán Bonner and Patrick Boner

The Cope in Dungloe has returned a historic cup associated with Dr William Smyth and his yacht Stella to Arranmore, after keeping it safely in their care for approximately 30 years.

The cup, inscribed “Arranmore Regatta 1901”, was awarded to Dr Smyth in recognition of his sailing prowess in his yacht Stella.

Dr Smyth was a doctor serving the Rosses and died at the age of just 42 after contracting typhus while treating patients on Arranmore. He left his wife Esther and eight children.

Dr Smyth and Estherplaceholder image
Dr Smyth and Esther | Seán Bonner and Patrick Boner

Following Dr Smyth's death, his wife Esther kept the trophy. It eventually went to Bangor, Co. Down, when she moved there to live with her daughter, Mary Hamill Russell, née Smyth. In 1975, Mary decided that the cup should return to Donegal.

In a letter to her brother Willie, dated 6 December 1975, she wrote that she was giving the Donegal Historical Society “the last cup won by the ‘Stella’ in 1901”, along with a large framed photograph of her father. She felt that these items should have “a permanent home where they would be appreciated and cared for.”

Dr Smyth Cupplaceholder image
Dr Smyth Cup | Seán Bonner and Patrick Boner

The Donegal Historical Society subsequently placed the cup in the Arranmore Dispensary. In 1976, the Society also commemorated Dr Smyth's heroism by placing a plaque on the old lifeboat shed in Leabgarrow.

When the Arranmore Dispensary was being redeveloped around 1990, the Donegal Historical Society needed somewhere secure to keep the cup and approached The Cope. The Cope very kindly agreed to take it into safekeeping, where it remained for more than three decades in a glass cabinet upstairs in the Dungloe store.

The cup has now been returned to Arranmore, with the handover taking place at the Arranmore Lifeboat Station as part of the launch of the Trasna Na dTonnta’s campaign to participate in The World's Toughest Row - a 3,000-mile journey across the Atlantic in December 2026 by Sharon (mum) and two sons Evan and Glenn.

Mark Sharkey, CEO of The Cope, along with Seán Bonner, formally handed the cup over to Noreen Muldowney (Sharon’s sister), Manager of Comhar Chumann Arainn Mhór Teoranta.

Seán Bonner has played an important role in researching the history of the cup and facilitating its return. His research has also uncovered a fascinating connection between Dr Smyth and Stella, including a reference to “Stella 1901 Arranmore Regatta” recorded on the back of a window shutter at Roshine Lodge in Burtonport, where Dr Smyth lived and died.

The Stellaplaceholder image
The Stella | Seán Bonner and Patrick Boner

Seán's father, Pádraig Ó Cnáimhsí, also wrote the Irish-language book Roise Rua, which tells the story of Roise Green of Arranmore. The book was translated into English by the late J.J. Keaveney of Moville and was republished by Mercier Press last year.

Dr Smyth is buried in the Church of Ireland graveyard in Dungloe, and his descendants have visited the area over the years. His story remains particularly well known on Arranmore.

The return of the cup is also particularly timely given the island's continuing connection with rowing and maritime heritage, with the Trasna Na dTonnta boat having recently completed its own rowing journey around Ireland.

Sharon, Evan and Glennplaceholder image
Sharon, Evan and Glenn | Seán Bonner and Patrick Boner

The Cope has been honoured to have acted as custodian of this piece of local history for more than 30 years, and there is a real sense that the cup has now come home to the community with which its history is so closely connected.

Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice