Senator Tom Clonan to address Roscommon meeting amid Triple Lock misinformation claims


Tom Clonan warns that removing the Triple Lock could threaten Ireland’s neutrality and change the role of Irish troops overseas
Independent Senator Tom Clonan, who has accused the Government of conducting a “robust campaign of misinformation” over the Triple Lock, will address a public meeting in Roscommon Town this Thursday, November 19.
The retired Army captain and security analyst has been strongly critical of proposals to remove the Triple Lock, warning that the move could fundamentally alter Ireland’s military neutrality and its role in international peacekeeping.
“The government are engaged in a very robust campaign of misinformation about the triple lock. I'm sorry to say that,” he said in a recent video interview circulated online. “The government are saying they're going to reform the triple lock. They're not. They're simply removing it.”
Clonan has also raised concerns about the potential implications for Irish troops serving in Lebanon, warning that traditional peacekeeping operations could give way to more aggressive peace enforcement missions involving Hezbollah. "The government have been engaged in a lot of misinformation on this," he said. "They're just removing it. They're not reforming it. They're simply abolishing it."
Senator Clonan warned that the proposed changes could have serious consequences for Irish soldiers, particularly those deployed on overseas missions without a United Nations mandate. "When I joined the Defence Forces in the 80s, you had to be a volunteer for overseas service. But now you don't have to be a volunteer, you can be ordered to serve overseas," he said. "So young soldiers don't have any choice anymore in where they're sent."
He pointed to proposals for future Irish involvement in Ukraine and Lebanon, arguing that soldiers could be ordered to serve in potentially dangerous missions.
"If a soldier was sent on that, they'd have no choice," he said, referring to a possible deployment to Ukraine following a ceasefire. The Senator was particularly critical of plans for Irish participation in a proposed EU mission in Lebanon following the conclusion of the current UN peacekeeping mission.
"If we sent any soldiers on that mission without a UN mandate, we're no longer militarily neutral because we would be participating in a war on the side of the Lebanese government against Hezbollah, whilst there are still Israeli soldiers in South Lebanon," he claimed.
"So, you know, it just changes things forever. So that would increase hugely the risk to our soldiers. But it would also increase the risk to our entire diaspora."
He warned that Ireland's international reputation for neutrality could also be affected. "Young Irish people travelling all around the world in Irish passports, they have a certain amount of protection because of the Irish passport. But if we get rid of our neutrality, that's gone." Senator Clonan also raised concerns about pay and conditions for Defence Forces personnel deployed on missions without UN authorisation.
"If they're sent on a non-UN mission, they won't get any extra pay for it. So they'll be separated from their families for considerable periods of time and won't get any extra money," he claimed.
He argues that such deployments could effectively place Irish forces on the same side as Israel in a military conflict, compromising the country's longstanding policy of neutrality. “Once our armed forces are committed in that way, we are no longer neutral,” he warned. His comments come as the Roscommon Neutrality Network hosts two public information evenings examining the future of the Triple Lock and Ireland's military neutrality.
The first meeting takes place this evening, Monday, November 16, with former Fianna Fáil TD and government minister Éamon Ó Cuív delivering the keynote address. He will be joined by former Roscommon-Galway TD and Senator Eugene Murphy and chartered psychologist Marian Naughton, a member of Lex Innocentium 21st Century.
The second meeting, on Thursday, November 19, will feature Senator Clonan alongside Dr Karen Devine, Assistant Professor of Politics at Dublin City University. The Triple Lock mechanism requires Government approval, Dáil approval and UN authorisation for certain overseas deployments of Irish Defence Forces personnel. The Government has argued that reform is necessary to prevent permanent members of the UN Security Council from exercising a veto over Irish participation in international missions.
Both meetings will take place at Gleesons, Market Square, Roscommon Town, from 6pm to 8pm, with free parking available at the nearby town car park.
