SNP ministers urged to ‘swallow some humble pie’ and ditch food price cap plan

A man with a trolley looking at groceries in a supermarketplaceholder image
A man with a trolley looking at groceries in a supermarket

The Scottish Retail Consortium issued the plea ahead of a consultation on the controversial proposal closing on Tuesday November 24.

Retail chiefs have urged the Scottish Government to “swallow some humble pie” and ditch plans to bring in a food price cap – insisting the idea is one of the “most ill considered policies” from Holyrood in the last decade.

The Scottish Government is currently consulting on controversial plans from First Minister John Swinney to bring in a price cap on dozens of essential food stuffs.

Announced during the election campaign, it was promoted as offering financial help to Scots struggling in the midst of the cost of living crisis.

With the consultation due to close on Tuesday the Scottish Retail Consortium (SRC) – which has been highly critical of the plan – insisted ministers should ditch the “potty election gimmick”.

But the SRC insists that Scottish shoppers already “benefit from the lowest prices in Western Europe due to intense competition between retailers”.

It adds that retailers have reduced profit margins in a bid to keep prices down for customers, with the organisation also warning government action to curb prices could have “significant unintended deleterious consequences” – such as higher prices for shoppers, increased imports of foreign products and reduced supply.

Hitting out at the “nebulous nature of the proposed price caps” the SRC says that seven months after it was first unveiled “Scottish ministers do not yet know what the policy is, who it will help, who will be affected, how it could be implemented, or whether it is within the competency of the Scottish Parliament”.

Speaking ahead of the consultation closing, SRC deputy head Ewan MacDonald-Russell, said: “It’s time ministers focused on policies which will work, not empty populist soundbites.”

Saying that stores have worked “to take every step possible to help struggling shoppers” over recent months, he added: “Millions have been spent keeping down the price of essential goods.

“Food inflation has stayed under 3% despite the rocketing cost of fuel and energy.

placeholder image

“In the same period Scottish ministers have produced a peely-wally price cap consultation paper which completely fails to make the case they could set prices better than the market.”

Mr MacDonald-Russell continued: “The price cap policy may have been conceived as a potty election gimmick. But the negative consequences would be immense.

“Similar policies elsewhere forced retailers to reduce ranges and bring in imports at the expense of local suppliers.

“Products in-scope ran out. There were increased tensions in store. Small retailers lost out.

“Despite all this, price caps in Croatia, Hungary, France, and elsewhere did little to nothing to stop food inflation rises.”

Urging ministers to ditch the plans, he said the food price cap proposal was “amongst the most ill-considered policies directed towards business to emanate from Holyrood in the past decade”.

Mr MacDonald-Russell said: “It tramples all over the pledges in the Scottish Government’s legislative programme and New Deal for Business to ‘regulate last’ and involve commerce at the inception of policy development.

“Scots benefit from the most affordable food prices in Europe. That’s because we have, as the Government’s own consultation acknowledges, a highly efficient and competitive grocery market.

“It’s time for Government to swallow some humble pie and ditch the cap. Instead of spending years, and millions of pounds, developing and enforcing a pointless policy, Scottish minsters need to get to grips with the drivers and consequences of inflation.”

Minister for business Tom Arthur said: “The purpose of the consultation is to test both the principle of a price cap and how any future scheme could be best implemented.

“Food affordability continues to place pressure on households, particularly those on lower incomes, and it is right that this Government considers what more can be done.

“I have engaged closely with businesses throughout the consultation and when the consultation closes on Tuesday, all views and evidence will be carefully considered.”

Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice