“Bring back the machines” – Galway City Councillors vote yes to their return after long debate

placeholder image
Iconic

From parking figures branded “bunkum” to concerns over accessibility and lost shoppers, a two-hour Galway City Council debate revealed deep frustrations over the 18-month parking controversy.

A comeback is on the cards for Galway's pay-and-display parking machines, after city councillors voted in favour of restoring the service at key locations across the city.

The decision came despite a recommendation from the council executive that the machines should not be reintroduced “at this point” in what has been described as a “significant breakthrough” after the controversy that has rumbled on for 18 months.

The motion to reintroduce parking payment machines was put forward at a meeting of Galway City Council by Cllr Clodagh Higgins (FG) and seconded by Cllr Alan Curran (SocDem).

At the meeting, Cllr Higgins (FG) dismissed as “bunkum” figures in September's parking report indicating that revenue had returned to previous levels.

“I have serious concerns about how the debacle has been managed,” she said at the meeting.

“We have increased our charges and listening to a report that we are back up is bunkum. To say that we are back up at what we were at in 2024 is really disingenuous.”

Cllr Higgins argued that the increase in parking charges should have led to an increase in revenue for the city.

She asked who made the decision to take the pay-and-display machines out of service as Galway City Council had made a commitment to the electorate in 2024.

She described the current situation as “bonkers” especially given the fact that the parking app was being advertised in cinemas.

And she requested whether or not the newly appointed accessibility officer was consulted.

“I am opposed to removing choice without a transparent business case,” she said.

“What is stopping the council from whipping off the covers and allowing people to have the opportunity to pay for parking on the street?”

Cllr Higgins also warned of the reputational damage the parking controversy had caused Galway.

Meanwhile, Cllr Donal Lyons (Ind) said that the city's parking arrangements were driving shoppers to Athlone and Limerick, while Cllr Mike Cubbard (Ind) suggested that public buildings should be used as Payzone payment locations.

Independent Cllr Eibhlín Seoighthe disputed suggestions that complaints had fallen, while Cllr Frank Fahy (FG) highlighted the confusion facing tourists who encountered machines with signs stating they were temporarily out of order.

“18 months in my book is not temporary,” he said.

Cllr Terry O'Flaherty (Ind) called for the machines to be brought back into use, while Mayor of Galway City Cllr Helen Ogbu (Lab) summed up the debate by saying that “the slogan is to bring back the machines”.

Having outlined the timeline of events that culminated in High Court proceedings against Galway City Council, Director of Services Patrick Greene said the council had received two tenders at the time.

Mr Greene said the machines were fully taken out of commission in July 2025, by which time around half had stopped working.

“We took the decision to take them out of commission as they were only causing havoc,” he said.

He denied that an operator had offered €100,000 to buy the machines and said that the existing machines “are not fit for purpose”.

Responding to a query from Cllr Higgins, he confirmed that all cash had been removed from the machines after they were taken out of service.

Both the Director of Service and Chief Executive Leonard Cleary expressed a preference for card-only machines should they be restored.

Mr Greene said a balance would need to be struck regarding the number and location of machines, and said that the council could face challenges if too few were installed.

Meanwhile, Chief Executive Leonard Cleary said further discussion was needed on whether new machines would accept cards and/or coins, and that the service would have to go out to tender.

While he could not comment on the High Court case, he said he “stands over the procurement process” and that the settlement “reflected the least cost to this council”.

“There are no winners when anyone goes to the High Court,” he said.

He confirmed that the vote to reintroduce the machines would not affect the draft budget presented to councillors, saying the costs could be reviewed once tender prices were available.

“I wouldn't be in favour of tweaking the budget,” he said. “When the facts of the tender price are available, we can review the budget. We should be able to reprioritise,” he said.

Afterwards, Cllr Higgins said that “the job is not finished” and she wants to see “meaningful engagement”.

“After 18 months, Galway deserves a practical resolution to this issue. I intend to ensure that the decision taken by Council is followed through,” she said.

Funded by the Local Democracy Reporting Scheme

Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice